Mental Health Comorbidities in Workers’ Compensation Patients and the Effect on Pain, Disability, Quality of Life, and Return to Work After Lumbar Spine Surgery

Introduction: Outcomes after lumbar spine surgery in workers’ compensation (WC) patients have been reported to be worse than the general population. Anxiety and depression are modifiable risk factors that also adversely affect outcomes after lumbar spine surgery. We aimed to determine whether WC patients with mental health comorbidities represent the most vulnerable of lumbar spine surgery patients.

Methods: We queried a nationwide, prospective surgical outcomes registry (AANS-QOD) for all patients undergoing lumbar spine surgery at over 200 hospital systems from 2012 to 2021. Perioperative safety, facility utilization, one-year patient-reported outcomes (pain, disability, and quality-of-life), and return to work (RTW) were measured as a function of WC and mental health comorbidity status.

Results: A total of 27,525 patients (1018 WC, 26,507 non-WC) undergoing 1-4 level lumbar spine surgery (14,914 laminectomy, 12,611 fusion) were reviewed. WC patients were younger, healthier (lower ASA grade), more likely to be minorities, less educated, more likely to smoke, and had greater baseline back pain, disability, and quality of life compared to non-WC patients. The prevalence of anxiety and depression was similar between groups. WC patients had worse outcomes for all measures and lower rates of RTW compared to non-WC patients. WC patients with anxiety and depression demonstrated even greater disparities in all outcomes. After propensity matching, WC patients with anxiety or depression (n=107) continued to demonstrate significantly worse outcomes in comparison to WC patients without anxiety or depression (n=107).

Conclusion : Disparities in outcomes after lumbar spine surgery in WC patients are exacerbated in patients with anxiety and depression. WC patients with mental health comorbidities receive the least benefit from lumbar spine surgery and may represent the most vulnerable subset of patients with spinal pathology. Addressing mental health comorbidities preoperatively may represent an opportunity for valuable resource allocation and surgical optimization in the WC population.